Is Ayurveda better than allopathy for treating palpitations?

Question

Hello doctor,

I am a 25-year-old male. Two months ago, I found myself in a very frightening situation that caused me to panic. I consulted a psychiatrist who prescribed Clonazepam, Propranolol, and antidepressants. After taking them for seven to ten days, I stopped, fearing their addictive nature. After discontinuing the medication, I began experiencing new issues such as heart palpitations whenever I tried to sleep during the day, irregular nighttime sleep, and increased anxiety. Although the symptoms have lessened over time, I still experience palpitations when trying to sleep. I took Medhavati for 12 to 14 days, which somewhat improved my nighttime sleep, but I did not feel fully refreshed.

I then consulted a general doctor who suggested it was just a phobia and prescribed a combination of Clonazepam and Escitalopram for 15 days, along with multivitamins. I also sought advice from an Ayurvedic specialist who recommended Manasamitra vatakam, Stresswin, and Saraswatiristam.

I would appreciate guidance on whether I should continue with these Ayurvedic medicines or opt for antidepressants for 15 days. Are Manasamitra and Saraswatiristam safe and free from significant side effects? How long does it typically take for these Ayurvedic treatments to show effects, and for how long should I take them? Although I am feeling better overall, I still struggle with daytime sleep due to palpitations and occasional negative, fearful thoughts. Does Manasamitra increase serotonin levels in the brain and promote enthusiasm? Should I continue with Ayurvedic medicine or switch to allopathic treatment for faster results?

Please help.

Answer 1

Hello,

Welcome to icliniq.com.

I understand the confusion and mental pain you are experiencing. Currently, there is limited research on combining allopathic drugs with Ayurvedic or Siddha treatments. In your case, I recommend continuing the allopathic medications for 15 days (or longer, as advised by your physician). Additionally, you might consider taking Propranolol to help reduce palpitations. To minimize the risk of addiction, a gradual reduction in dosage is advisable. For example, starting from day 16, you could take half a tablet for the following week, then every other day for the next week, every fourth day for the subsequent week, and then discontinue. This should be done under the guidance of your physician.

Some animal studies suggest that Manasamitra tablets might increase serotonin levels, though there is no absolute guarantee. Many clinical observations indicate that these three Ayurvedic treatments are effective if started early in the condition and are beneficial for long-term use. Therefore, incorporating these Ayurvedic drugs could be advantageous in your case.

Continue with the Ayurvedic medications for the next six months and consider joining a regular yoga class or training session daily during this period. In my experience, after six months, you may be able to discontinue all medications, including Ayurvedic ones, and maintain a healthy life solely through yoga practice. Yoga is a cost-free practice that has helped many individuals find significant relief from anxiety and depression, improving their focus, sleep, and overall well-being. Additionally, engaging in hobbies you enjoy—such as caring for plants, pets, observing fish, walking, playing, picnicking, or visiting temples—can be beneficial in managing stress and anxiety.

I hope this information is helpful.

Answer 2

Hello,

Welcome back to icliniq.com.

I understand your concern.

In psychiatric conditions, the disease rarely persists continuously. Often, symptoms are periodic, triggered by stimulation, provocation, or occurring randomly. Therefore, it is important not to assume the disease is completely cured just because the symptoms have resolved. A holistic approach is required, which includes medication, support from family and friends, improvements in economic and educational factors, and psychological counseling. Ideally, medication should only be taken during symptom episodes, not continuously. Unfortunately, we may not always recognize when symptoms arise and may not seek medical advice promptly.

If you maintain a positive outlook, you should consult a physician whenever symptoms appear and follow their prescribed treatment. Recovery does not happen automatically; it requires both mental and physical support. Additionally, I recommend consulting a psychological counselor who can help you develop strategies to overcome these challenges. Incorporating yoga and pranayama into your routine can also help you lead a fulfilling life without relying on medication. This is my personal advice.

For immediate symptom control, please continue with the allopathic drugs. Ayurvedic treatments can be appropriate for this condition but may take at least two weeks to show minimal results. Improvement may continue for a longer period even after stopping the drugs. Ayurvedic remedies are beneficial for preventing future symptoms, but they are not necessary for everyone. If you choose to use them, be aware that they will also take about two weeks to show effects.

Excess salivation is typically due to increased parasympathetic activity, which can be triggered by sour foods, certain drugs, or psychological factors such as excitement or thoughts about appealing flavors. Anticholinergic drugs can be used to reduce salivation, usually administered before surgery to manage salivation during the procedure. If the excessive salivation is persistent and bothersome, consider discussing it with your physician. Otherwise, it may be best to ignore it.

I hope this helps you.

Thank you.